.

1. Rev. James O'Connor 1856
2. Rev. Dr. James Keogh 1856-1857
3. Rev. John Hackett 1857
4. Rev. Jerome Kearney 1858-1877
5. Rev. James Francis Holland 1877
6. Very Rev. Stephen Wall 1878
7. Rev. James A. Canevin 1878-1881
8. Rev. Andrew J. Brown 1881-1884
9. Rev. James Cosgrove 1884-1889
10. Rev. Dr. Edward M. McKeever 1889-1891
11. Rev. William Graham 1891-1898
12. Rev. Phillip Brady 1898-1902
13. Rev. Hugh F. McCullough 1902-1913
14. Rev. Monsignor William Kittell
15. Rev. A.M. Benedik (Acting Pastor) 1928-1929
16. Rev. John Padden 1929-1934
17. Rev. Patrick Rice ( Acting Pastor ) 1933-1935
18. Rev. Patrick J. Kitrick 1935-1955
19. Right Rev. Monsignor Cyril J Vogel 1955-1965
20. Rev. Monsignor James O.D. Hanlan 1966-1974
21. Rev. Monsignor John C. Conway 1975-1983
22. Rev. Francis L. Ginocchi 1983-1985
23. Rev. Monsignor William G. Charnoki 1985-1994
24. Rev. Monsignor Donald J. Mondello 1994-2004
25. Rev. Donald B. Conroy 2004-2006
26. Rev. Daniel C. Mahoney 2006- present

.

.

1. Rev. Anthony J. Galagher 1899
2. Rev. Patrick J. Hesson 1900-1902
3. Rev. F.C. Shea 1904-1905
4. Rev. Benjamin N. Axmacher 1906
5. Rev. J. P. Shields 1906
6. Rev. Joseph Rossman 1907
7. Rev. Daniel A. Lawless 1907-1917
8. Rev. Matthias J. Spang 1917-1919
9. Rev. James A. Healy 1917-1921
10. Rev. Anthony M. Benedik 1919-1932
11. Rev. Edward J. Nemmer 1921-1922
12. Rev. William J. Spiegel 1922-1928
13. Rev. Alber L. Farina 1928-1933
14. Rev. Patrick W. Rice 1933-1937
15. Rev. Edwin R. Heyl 1933-1938
16. Rev. Thomas J. Quigley 1937
17. Rev. William F. Frawley 1938-1954
18. Rev. Arthur E. O'Shea 1939-1940
19. Rev. John H. McMahon 1941-1943
20. Rev. John Sieczkowski 1943-1944
21. Rev. Charles F. Schafer 1944
22. Rev. James F. Harvey 1944-1945
23. Rev. Thomas F. O'Connor 1942-1949
24. Rev. John Meighen 1951-1958
25. Rev. Francis Ott 1953-1956
26. Rev. William Coleman 1949-1953
27. Rev. David Fisher 1958-1960
28. Rev. Francis Ginnochi 1956-1960
29. Rev. Lawrence Hoppe 1960-1963
30. Rev. Dennis Sweeney 1958-1962
31. Rev. John Wilt 1962-1964
32. Rev. Thomas Lukac 1963-1965
33. Rev. Aloysusis Bahleda 1964-1967
34. Rev. Raymond Saptti 1965-1967
35. Rev. Joseph Batya 1967-1969
36. Rev. Angelo Ciuffoleti 1967-1968
37. Rev. Elmer Kacinko 1968-1970
38. Rev. John Regoli 1969-1970
39. Rev. Robert Byrnes 1970-1971
40. Rev. John Sweeney 1970-1975
41. Rev. James Popochock 1971-1974
42. Rev. Ronald Rutkowski 1974-1976
43. Rev. Ronald Simboli 1974-1976
44. Rev. Paul Fitzmaurice 1976-1979
45. Rev. Lawrence T Persico 1976-1977
46. Rev. Roger A. Sinclair 1977-1979
47. Rev. John W. Alverson 1979-1981
48. Rev. John T. Euker 1979-1981
49. Rev. J. Justin Grose 1981-1982
50. Rev. Peter L. Peretti 1981-1982
51. Rev. William C. McGuirk 1982-1984
52. Rev. Joseph Minsterman 1984-1985
53. Rev. Joseph O'Brien 1985-1990
54. Rev. Paul A. Lisik 1985-1987
55. Rev. Robert M. Waslko 1989-1990
56. Rev. Salvatore R. Lamendola 1990-1995
57. Rev. Alan Grote 1995-2005
58. Rev. Robert T. Lubic 2005-2007
59. Rev. Timothy Kuthrupt 2006- Present

* Starting in 1917 there were two assistant pastors. After 1990 there was only one assistant pastor.

.